Collections
Young mothers and girls of the Refuge Home with their looms. Adana, 1919.
Location
Adana, Turkey
Year
1919
Item Detail
Three of the young women at the Refuge Home were "girl-mothers with Turkish babies," and one of them asked Miss Webb, "Shall I not hate my baby?" Elizabeth S. Webb had charge of the Refuge Home at Adana. The relief program adopted by the trustees of Near East Relief included rescue homes for women and girls, with their babies, "escaped or discharged from Moslem harems."
Context
George Robert Swain (1866–1947) was the University of Michigan's photographer from 1913 to 1947. In 1919 and 1920, he photographed Francis W. Kelsey's expedition through Europe and the Near East, traveling with Kelsey, his wife Isabelle, and their son Easton. Kelsey went to study ancient sites and manuscripts and to see the region's refugee camps, orphanages and training schools for himself. Rear Admiral Mark L. Bristol, the American High Commissioner at Constantinople, arranged their train journey across Turkey by way of Adana and Tarsus to Aleppo in December 1919 and January 1920. Swain photographed the relief work they visited, as well as the staff of the Near East Relief and the YMCA.
This photograph is part of a group by Swain that NERHS selected to document relief work and the places it served. Most come from the Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, which holds the expedition negatives. The rest are captioned prints from Swain's papers at the Bentley Historical Library, which received the papers from Edwin L. Swain, the Kelsey Museum, and Mrs. D. W. Hayne. Two lantern slides copy Near East Relief cables from 1921. NERHS downloaded the files from the University of Michigan Library Digital Collections in October 2026.
-
Holding Institution
Bentley Historical Library (University of Michigan)
-
External Link
-
Attribution
"Group in the Refuge Home in Adana in charge of Miss Eliz. S. Webb, December 1919 [no. 154]; HS12713." In the digital collection Bentley Historical Library: Bentley Image Bank. https://quod.lib.umich.edu/b/bhl/x-hs12713/hs12713. University of Michigan Library Digital Collections. © Regents of the University of Michigan.
-
Rights
This material is made available by Bentley Historical Library, University of Michigan under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. NERHS displays it in accordance with that license for non-commercial, educational purposes, with attribution to the source. Users are responsible for compliance with the license terms for any downstream reuse. Full license terms: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. If you believe you hold rights in this material or have information about rights holders not currently reflected, please contact [email protected].
-
Notes
Bentley title: "Group in the Refuge Home in Adana in charge of Miss Eliz. S. Webb, December 1919 [no. 154]"
Bentley date: December 1919
Bentley note: Typescript commentary attached to another print of this image adds: "Three girl-mothers with Turkish babies are in the foreground. it was one of these who said to Miss Webb "Shall I not hate my baby?" with a hint at its destruction."
Bentley folder: Expedition photographs & commentary (2)
Photographer: George R. Swain (Ann Arbor, MI). Scan source: 6.3 x 10.2 inches photo print.
Bentley record: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/b/bhl/x-hs12713/hs12713The Kelsey Museum record of the same negative:
Kelsey Museum title: "Group of Miss Webb’s girls in the courtyard with looms, machines, etc. Three or four Armenian girl-mothers at the left in the foreground."
Kelsey date: December 31 1919
Kelsey location: Turkey, Adana
Creator: Swain, George R. Material: Paper.
Kelsey record: https://quod.lib.umich.edu/k/kelsey/x-7.0154/1Sources for the Item Detail:
• Bentley Historical Library, HS12713, typescript commentary attached to another print of the image ("Three girl-mothers with Turkish babies are in the foreground. it was one of these who said to Miss Webb "Shall I not hate my baby?""): https://quod.lib.umich.edu/b/bhl/x-hs12713/hs12713
• Barton, p. 117 (the commission's recommendations "were approved and adopted officially by the Board of Trustees and became the basis of future operations in all the relief areas"), and p. 119 ("The establishment of rescue homes for women and girls, with their babies, escaped or discharged from Moslem harems, giving them the same care as the orphans"; "The organization of industrial enterprises for the purpose of teaching orphans and rescued women trades as well as to assist in their support"). James L. Barton, Story of Near East Relief (1930), HathiTrust: http://hdl.handle.net/2027/uc1.$b744679
About this group: George R. Swain's photographs of Francis W. Kelsey's expedition, 1919–1920. Kelsey Archival Photographs Collections, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, University of Michigan, and George Robert Swain photographs and papers, Bentley Historical Library, University of Michigan.
• Bentley Historical Library, George Robert Swain photographs and papers, collection guide (creator "Swain, George Robert, 1866-1947"; "university photographer from 1913 to 1947"; he "began his work on campus with Professor Francis W. Kelsey of the Latin Department"; "The collection came from three different sources: Mr. Edwin L. Swain ... the University's Kelsey Museum ... and Mrs. D. W. Hayne"): https://findingaids.lib.umich.edu/catalog/umich-bhl-86169
• Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, "A Man of Many Parts: The Life and Legacy of Francis Willey Kelsey," online exhibition, The First Expedition ("The team was small: Francis, Isabelle, Easton, and photographer George Swain"; the objectives included "collecting photographs of ancient sites and monuments" and "studying biblical manuscripts in European libraries and monastery collections"; "Bristol arranged for the group to travel in a ramshackle train across Turkey via Adana and Tarsus to Syrian Aleppo"): https://exhibitions.kelsey.lsa.umich.edu/fwk/first_ex.html
• Thelma K. Thomas, Dangerous Archaeology: Francis Willey Kelsey and Armenia (1919–1920) (1990), online exhibition, "Francis Kelsey's Expedition and Armenia" ("Rear Admiral Mark Bristol, U.S. High Commissioner of the city"; Kelsey "saw for himself the refugee camps, orphanages and training schools"): https://exhibitions.kelsey.lsa.umich.edu/galleries/Exhibits/DangerousArchaeology/PartTwo.html
• Sebastián Encina, "From the Archives #61," The Kelsey Blog, Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, December 22, 2020 ("For December 1919 alone, we have records for 376 Swain photographs"; "Francis Kelsey was heavily involved in the relief effort following the Armenian genocide"): https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/kelsey-museum-blog/2020/12/22/from-the-archives-61/
• Kelsey Museum of Archaeology, "Surrounded by the View: Panoramic Photographs from the Kelsey Museum Archives," exhibition, January to August 2000 ("Among Swain's photographic equipment was a Cirkut camera, one of the earliest rotation cameras manufactured for commercial use"): https://prod.lsa.umich.edu/kelsey/exhibitions/special-exhibitions/past/surrounded-by-the-view.html


