1878–1914

The Armenian Question

Most Ottoman Armenians lived in Central and Eastern Anatolia. The Armenian population was largest in the vilayets closest to the Russian and Persian borders, including Van, Erzurum, and Bitlis.

The Ottoman Empire and the Russian Empire went to war repeatedly in the 1800s. As a Christian Empire, Russia felt a kinship with the Christians living under Ottoman rule. The Russo-Turkish War of 1877-1878 was a mission to liberate Russia’s Christian counterparts from Ottoman rule while expanding Russian territories.

Scholars estimate that approximately 2 million Armenians were living in the Ottoman Empire when World War I began in 1914 (estimates range from 1.5 to 2.1 million). The war brought the Armenian Question, as it was known, to the international stage.

Armenian women in holiday attire, Artvin, ca. 1909–1912

1800–1909

Oppression and Violence

Abdul Hamid II at his accession, 1876

Sultan Abdul Hamid

The Ottoman Empire was ruled by the sultan from the capital city of Constantinople.

Sultan Abdul Hamid II enjoyed absolute power over the territories of the Ottoman Empire from 1876 until 1908. Sultan Abdul Hamid had a special hatred for the Ottoman Armenians.

Sunni Islam was the official religion of the Empire, and minority groups – including Christian Armenians, Greeks, Assyrians, and Ottoman Jews – were dhimmi: non-Muslim subjects living under Ottoman Turkish protection at the will of the Sultan.

Religious minorities were permitted to worship but were denied the rights of full citizenship.

Non-Muslims were subject to additional taxes and were barred from the Islamic court system. They were not allowed to own weapons, making them vulnerable to attacks from Turks and Kurds.

The missionary school system had produced an educated class of Armenians that began to advocate for civil and political rights. But political activism could lead to kidnapping, torture, or execution.

“I will soon settle these Armenians. I will give them a box on the ear which will make them smart and relinquish their revolutionary ambitions.”

- Sultan Abdul Hamid II, 1890, to German traveler and writer Arminius Vambery

The Sultan was true to his word.

By the end of the 1890s, between 100,000 and 300,000 people had been killed in the Hamidian Massacres.

1906–1908

Political Opposition

Major Enver in uniform, Salonica, ca. 1908–1911

The Young Turks

This highly charged political atmosphere gave rise to an opposition group called the Young Turks, which opposed the sultan and sought a constitutional government. The Young Turks joined forces with the revolutionary Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) in 1906. Minority populations supported the CUP because it promised additional rights to non-Muslims. Armenians saw the CUP as a welcome change from the brutal Hamidian regime.

The July 1908 Young Turk Revolution forced Sultan Abdul Hamid II to restore the 1876 constitution and recall parliament, ending his absolute rule. He was deposed in April 1909, after the failed countercoup known as the 31 March Incident.

1909–1913

Adana — street in the Christian quarter, June 1909
Adana — street in the Christian quarter, June 1909

The Adana Massacre

For a few brief months it seemed as if peace was possible. But in April 1909, counterrevolutionaries in Constantinople sought to restore Sultan Abdul Hamid. As news of the counterrevolution spread, an enraged mob besieged the prosperous Armenian community in the far-off city of Adana. The countercoup was quickly suppressed, and the CUP emerged as an efficient and brutal governing body. Young Turk soldiers were ordered to Adana under the pretense of restoring order. Instead, they further brutalized the city, claiming that the Armenians provoked them.

By the end of April 1909, thousands of Armenians had been massacred at Adana. The city was almost completely destroyed.

Djemal Pasha reviewing Armenian orphans, Damascus
Djemal Pasha reviewing Armenian orphans, Damascus

Turkification

The government adopted a policy of Turkification – the forced transition from the multicultural Ottoman Empire to a homogeneous Turkish state. Turkification was an extreme form of nationalism. The government implemented a paramilitary training program for young men. Launched in 1913, the Association for the Promotion of Turkish Strength trained young warriors for the fight for Turkish identity. Enver Pasha’s War Ministry provided free rifles to youth groups. Government propagandists argued that a strong society must have only one culture, one religion, and one level of education. CUP leaders portrayed non-Muslims as an invasive virus within the Turkish nation.

“You asked me how, being a doctor, I could have taken a life. Well, here is my answer: Those Armenian bandits were a bunch of harmful microbes pestering the body of this nation. A doctor’s duty is to kill microbes, isn’t it?”

- Dr. Mehmet Reshid, governor of Diarbekir vilayet. Dr. Reshid’s special strike force, known as the Butcher’s Battalion, was responsible for the death and deportation of hundreds of thousands of people.

The Young Turks fixed upon an answer to the longstanding Armenian Question: non-Muslim Ottoman subjects must be eliminated through deportation, imprisonment, and mass murder.

Hundreds of years of persecution culminated in genocide.

2

Next Chapter

The Genocide

Continue